Skip to main content

Comparison

Smoked Beer vs Specialty IPA (e.g. Milkshake IPA, Brut IPA, New England IPA) — What's the Difference?

Smoked Beer and Specialty IPA (e.g. Milkshake IPA, Brut IPA, New England IPA), compared side by side on the style data WhatDrink holds: strength, body, bitterness, sweetness, colour, flavour and food pairing.

Option A

Smoked Beer

medium body
BreadyMaltyToasty

Option B

Specialty IPA (e.g. Milkshake IPA, Brut IPA, New England IPA)

medium body
CitrusTropical FruitHoppy

Quick verdict

Smoked Beer is low-medium-bitterness vs Specialty IPA (e.g. Milkshake IPA, Brut IPA, New England IPA) at medium-high.

Smoked Beer vs Specialty IPA (e.g. Milkshake IPA, Brut IPA, New England IPA) — at a glance

DetailSmoked BeerSpecialty IPA (e.g. Milkshake IPA, Brut IPA, New England IPA)
Drink typeBeerBeer
BodyMediumMedium
SweetnessMediumMedium
BitternessLow-mediumMedium-high
AcidityLowLow
FlavorsBready, Malty, Toasty, SmokyCitrus, Tropical Fruit, Hoppy, Sweet
Food pairingsBBQ, Pork, Roast MeatWings, Burgers, Fried Chicken
Production methodBrewed with smoked malt or smoke-influenced ingredients to create woodsmoke, bacon or campfire notes.A top-fermented IPA base is adapted with extra hops, adjuncts, fruit, lactose, enzymes or haze-building grains.
Base materialssmoked malt, barley malt, hops, yeastpale malt, hops, ale yeast, style-specific additions
FermentationVaries by base beerTop fermentation
AgeingUsually not aged unless combined with barrel ageing.Usually consumed fresh rather than aged.
RegionBamberg, Germany, United StatesUnited States

— = data not available for this style.

Character difference

→ Smoked Beer

A type of beer that has been made with malts that have been smoked over a wood fire, imparting a distinct smoky flavor.

BreadyMaltyToastySmoky
First option

→ Specialty IPA (e.g. Milkshake IPA, Brut IPA, New England IPA)

A type of India Pale Ale that is made using unique or experimental ingredients or brewing techniques, such as Milkshake IPA, Brut IPA, and New England IPA.

CitrusTropical FruitHoppySweet
Second option

When to choose each

→ Smoked Beer

  • Reach for Smoked Beer when you are drawn to Bready notes in your glass
  • Reach for Smoked Beer when a Malty character appeals to you

→ Specialty IPA (e.g. Milkshake IPA, Brut IPA, New England IPA)

  • Reach for Specialty IPA (e.g. Milkshake IPA, Brut IPA, New England IPA) when you are drawn to Citrus notes in your glass
  • Reach for Specialty IPA (e.g. Milkshake IPA, Brut IPA, New England IPA) when a Tropical Fruit character appeals to you

Food pairings

Smoked Beer

  • BBQ
  • Pork
  • Roast Meat
  • Smoked Meats

Specialty IPA (e.g. Milkshake IPA, Brut IPA, New England IPA)

  • Wings
  • Burgers
  • Fried Chicken
  • Spicy Food
  • Tacos

Methodology