Skip to main content

Comparison

Malbec vs Syrah / Shiraz — What's the Difference?

Malbec and Syrah/Shiraz, compared side by side on the style data WhatDrink holds: strength, body, bitterness, sweetness, colour, flavour and food pairing.

Option A

Malbec

12–14.5% ABVMedium-Full bodyRed
Black FruitFull BodiedTannic

Option B

Syrah/Shiraz

12–14.5% ABVMedium-Full bodyRed
Black FruitPepperySpicy

Quick verdict

Malbec and Syrah/Shiraz are distinct styles with their own character. The choice comes down to flavour direction and occasion.

Malbec vs Syrah/Shiraz — at a glance

DetailMalbecSyrah/Shiraz
Drink typeWineWine
ABV range12–14.5% ABV12–14.5% ABV
BodyMedium-FullMedium-Full
ColorRedRed
SweetnessDryDry
AcidityMediumMedium
FlavorsBlack Fruit, Full Bodied, Tannic, ChocolateBlack Fruit, Peppery, Spicy, Full Bodied
Food pairingsBBQ, Burgers, Korean BBQBBQ, Korean BBQ, Lamb
Production methodRed wine grapes are fermented on skins to build deep colour, ripe fruit, and tannin; many examples see oak maturation.Red wine made from Syrah/Shiraz grapes, fermented on skins for colour and tannin; oak maturation is common, especially for fuller-bodied styles.

— = data not available for this style.

Character difference

→ Malbec

A full-bodied red wine with high tannins and flavors of black cherry, plum, and chocolate.

Black FruitFull BodiedTannicChocolate
First option

→ Syrah/Shiraz

A medium- to full-bodied red wine whose fruit, spice, structure, and weight vary with region, climate, and winemaking.

Black FruitPepperySpicyFull Bodied
Second option

When to choose each

→ Malbec

  • Reach for Malbec when a Full Bodied character appeals to you

→ Syrah/Shiraz

  • Reach for Syrah/Shiraz when a Peppery character appeals to you

Food pairings

Malbec

  • BBQ
  • Burgers
  • Korean BBQ
  • Lamb
  • Steak

Syrah/Shiraz

  • BBQ
  • Korean BBQ
  • Lamb
  • Smoked Meats
  • Steak

Methodology