Skip to main content

Comparison

American Wild Ale vs Barley Wine — What's the Difference?

American Wild Ale and Barley Wine, compared side by side on the style data WhatDrink holds: strength, body, bitterness, sweetness, colour, flavour and food pairing.

Option A

American Wild Ale

medium body
EarthyFunkySour

Option B

Barley Wine

8–12% ABVfull body
MaltyFull BodiedSweet

Quick verdict

American Wild Ale is medium-bodied; Barley Wine is full-bodied.

American Wild Ale vs Barley Wine — at a glance

DetailAmerican Wild AleBarley Wine
Drink typeBeerBeer
ABV range—8–12% ABV
BodyMediumFull
SweetnessMediumMedium
BitternessLow-mediumLow-medium
AcidityLowLow
FlavorsEarthy, Funky, Sour, AcidicMalty, Full Bodied, Sweet, Caramel
Food pairingsCheese, Cheese Board, SaladsCheese Board, Chocolate, Dessert
Production methodFermented or conditioned with wild yeast and/or bacteria, often with extended ageing and sometimes fruit or barrel influence.High-gravity top-fermented ale with substantial malt, alcohol and hop structure; often benefits from ageing.
Base materialsmalt, wheat, hops, wild yeast, bacteriapale malt, specialty malt, hops, ale yeast
FermentationMixed fermentationTop fermentation
AgeingOften aged in barrels, tanks or bottles depending on producer.Often cellar-aged; some versions are barrel-aged.
RegionUnited StatesEngland, United States

— = data not available for this style.

Character difference

→ American Wild Ale

A beer style that is fermented with wild yeast or bacteria, resulting in a unique flavor profile.

EarthyFunkySourAcidic
First option

→ Barley Wine

A beer style that is characterized by a high alcohol content and a strong malt flavor, with notes of caramel and fruit.

MaltyFull BodiedSweetCaramel
Second option

When to choose each

→ American Wild Ale

  • Reach for American Wild Ale when you are drawn to Earthy notes in your glass
  • Reach for American Wild Ale when a Funky character appeals to you

→ Barley Wine

  • Reach for Barley Wine when you want richness and weight in the glass
  • Reach for Barley Wine when you want something stronger and spirit-adjacent

Food pairings

American Wild Ale

  • Cheese
  • Cheese Board
  • Salads
  • Seafood
  • Spicy Food

Barley Wine

  • Cheese Board
  • Chocolate
  • Dessert
  • Roast Meat

Methodology